- 2024: The Prom – May 16 to June 8, 2024
- 2024: Seussical The Musical – February 16 to March 10, 2024
- 2023: Fun Home – November 10 to 18, 2023
- 2023: Something Rotten! – May 12 to 27, 2023
- 2023: Disney’s Descendants The Musical – February 17 to March 5, 2023
- 2022: Heathers The Musical – November 11 to November 26, 2022
- 2021: Welcome Back Showcase – November 19 to November 27, 2021
- 2020: Matilda The Musical – February 14 to March 1, 2020
- 2019: The Rocky Horror Show – October 25 to November 9, 2019
- 2019: The Who’s Tommy – May 10 to May 25, 2019
- 2019: Broadway Dreamers – February 15 to March 3, 2019
- 2018: 9 to 5 The Musical – November 9 to November 24, 2018
- 2018: The Wedding Singer – May 11 to May 26, 2018
- 2018: High School Musical – February 16 to February 25, 2018
- 2017: Cry-Baby – November 10 to November 25, 2017
- 2017: Sister Act – May 12 to May 27, 2017
- 2017: Memories: A Celebration of 60 Years – February 10 to February 25, 2017
- 2016: The Toxic Avenger – November 11 to November 26, 2016
- 2016: Hair (HTI’s 60th Anniversary Show) – May 13 to May 28, 2016
- 2016: Broadway Showstoppers – February 12 to February 27, 2016
- 2015: Rent – November 13 to November 28, 2015
- 2015: Little Shop of Horrors – April 24 to May 9, 2015
- 2014: The Full Monty – November 28 to December 13, 2014
- 2014: Evita – May 2 to May 17, 2014
- 2014: You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown – February 14 to March 1, 2014
- 2013: Falsettos – November 15 to November 30, 2013
- 2013: Suds – April 26 to May 12, 2013
- 2013: Godspell – February 22 to March 9, 2013
- 2012: Blood Brothers – November 9 to November 24, 2012
- 2012: Xanadu – April 27 to May 12, 2012
- 2012: All Shook Up – February 17 to March 3, 2012
- 2011: Man of La Mancha – November 11 to November 26, 2011
- 2011: The World Goes ‘Round – April 29 to May 14, 2011
- 2011: The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee – February 18 to March 5, 2011
- 2010: Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street – November 12 to November 27, 2010
- 2010: Smokey Joe’s Cafe – April 23 to May 8, 2010
- 2009: Into the Woods – November 13 to November 22, 2009
- 2009: Hot Mikado – February 6 to February 8, 2009
- 2008: Jekyll & Hyde – November 7 to November 16, 2008
- 2008: South Pacific – April 11 to April 20, 2008
- 2007: Stage to Screen – December 7 to December 22, 2007
- 2007: Urinetown: The Musical – November 2 to November 11, 2007
- 2007: Anything Goes – April 13 to April 28, 2007
- 2006: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum – November 3 to November 18, 2006
- 2006: My Fair Lady (HTI’s 50th Anniversary Show) – April 7 to April 29, 2006
- 2005: Once Upon A Mattress – November 4 to November 19, 2005
- 2005: Rodgers and Hammerstein’s A Grand Night for Singing – April 1 to April 23, 2005
- 2004: A Christmas Survival Guide – December 3 to December 31, 2004
- 2004: I Love You, You’re Perfect, Now Change – September 24 to October 16, 2004
- 2004: Sugar Babies – April 16 to May 8, 2004
- 2003: Forever Plaid – December 12 to January 10, 2004
- 2003: Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor® Dreamcoat – October 17 to November 8, 2003
- 2003: Cabaret – April 11 to May 3, 2003
- 2003: Hats Off To Gershwin – January 10 to February 1, 2003
- 2002: You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown – October 18 to November 9, 2002
- 2002: Little Shop of Horrors – April 5 to April 20, 2002
- 2002: Twist and Shout – January 11 to January 26, 2002
- 2001: Leading Ladies – October 12 to October 27, 2001
- 2001: Pippin – March 23 to April 7, 2001
- 2000: Very Vaudeville – October 13 to October 28, 2000
- 2000: Bye Bye Birdie – April 28 to May 13, 2000
- 1999: Grease – December 3 to January 8, 2000
- 1999: Jerry’s Girls – October 1 to October 23, 1999
- 1999: The Secret Garden – April 23 to May 8, 1999
- 1998: The All Night Strut! – December 4 to January 2, 1999
- 1998: She Loves Me – October 23 to November 7, 1998
- 1998: Me and My Girl – April 17 to May 2, 1998
- 1997: The Fantasticks – December 5 to January 3, 1998
- 1997: Nunsense – October 10 to October 25, 1997
- 1997: La Cage aux Folles – April 25 to May 10, 1997
- 1996: The World Goes ‘Round – December 13 to January 18, 1997
- 1996: Back to Burlesque – October 4 to November 2, 1996
- 1996: Perfectly Frank – July 5 to July 27, 1996
- 1996: Oliver! (HTI’s 40th Anniversary Show) – April 25 to May 11, 1996
- 1995: Red Hot & Cole – December 15, 1995 to January 13, 1996
- 1995: A Chorus Line – October 20 to November 4, 1995
- 1995: Side by Side by Sondheim – July 7 to July 29, 1995
- 1995: Mame – April 21 to May 6, 1995
- 1994: Blame it on the Movies – December 9, 1994 to January 8, 1995
- 1994: My Favorite Year – October 28 to November 12, 1994
- 1994: A Fine and Private Place – July 8 to July 30, 1994
- 1994: Meet Me in St. Louis – April 8 to April 23, 1994
- 1993: The Saloonkeeper’s Daughter – December 10, 1993 to January 8, 1994
- 1993: The Boys from Syracuse – October 22 to November 7, 1993
- 1993: Godspell – July 2 to July 24, 1993
- 1993: Anything Goes – April 9 to April 24, 1993
- 1992: Pints, Pies and Pinups – November 27 to December 31, 1992
- 1992: Company – October 23 to November 7, 1992
- 1992: Nunsense – July 2 to July 25, 1992
- 1992: No, No, Nanette – April 17 to May 2, 1992
- 1991: Dames at Sea – November 30 to December 31, 1991
- 1991: Annie – October 18 to November 2, 1991
- 1991: Jerry’s Girls
- 1991: Follies
- 1990: Back to Burlesque
- 1990: Sweet Charity
- 1990: Razzle Dazzle
- 1990: 42nd Street
- 1989: Cabaret Nites
- 1989: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
- 1989: Little Shop of Horrors
- 1988: Guys and Dolls
- 1988: Sugar Babies
- 1987: Hello, Dolly!
- 1987: Peter Pan
- 1987: Chicago
- 1986: Barnum
- 1986: Brigadoon
- 1985: Annie Get Your Gun
- 1985: How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
- 1984: Oklahoma!
- 1984: Lost and Found
- 1984: Annie
- 1983: Half a Sixpence
- 1983: I’ll Die If I Can’t Live Forever
- 1983: The King and I
- 1982: The Unsinkable Molly Brown
- 1982: My Fair Lady
- 1981: One More Time (HTI’s 25th Anniversary Show)
- 1981: Cowardy Custard
- 1981: The Sound of Music
- 1980: Damn Yankees
- 1980: Fiddler on the Roof
- 1979: Anne of Green Gables
- 1979: Carousel
- 1978: Promises, Promises
- 1978: The Roar of the Greasepaint – The Smell of the Crowd
- 1977: L’il Abner
- 1977: The Pajama Game
- 1976: Dames at Sea
- 1976: Once Upon a Mattress
- 1976: A Little Night Music
- 1975: Gypsy: A Musical Fable
- 1975: Anything Goes
- 1975: Godspell
- 1974: Oliver!
- 1974: Cabaret
- 1973: Fiorello!
- 1973: Kismet
- 1972: Man of La Mancha
- 1972: The Music Man
- 1972: You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown
- 1971: Fiddler on the Roof
- 1971: Hello, Dolly!
- 1970: Oklahoma!
- 1970: Mame
- 1969: The King and I
- 1969: Sweet Charity
- 1968: Show Boat
- 1968: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
- 1967: Camelot
- 1967: How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
- 1966: The Sound of Music
- 1966: Guys and Dolls
- 1965: The Most Happy Fella
- 1965: West Side Story
- 1964: My Fair Lady
- 1964: Kiss Me, Kate
- 1963: Brigadoon
- 1963: Bye Bye Birdie
- 1962: The Music Man
- 1962: Flower Drum Song
- 1961: Annie Get Your Gun
- 1961: Can-Can
- 1960: South Pacific
- 1960: Oklahoma!
- 1959: Bells are Ringing
- 1959: Finian’s Rainbow
- 1958: The Pajama Game
- 1958: Guys and Dolls
- 1957: Plain and Fancy
- 1957: Carousel
- 1956: Brigadoon
- 1956: South Pacific
